YOUNGSTOWN, OH – Malachi McKinnon’s goal 2:20 into overtime completed the first comeback of the young season for the Youngstown Phantoms (7-9-1-0, 15pts) as they downed the Waterloo Black Hawks 3-2 Saturday night at the Covelli Centre. It was Youngstown’s first win of the year when trailing after two periods.
“I thought that was the best full game we played all season,” said Phantoms Head Coach Nathan Paetsch. “Top to bottom, every single guy, we played a really complete game.”
The game did not start well for the Phantoms, however, as Waterloo scored on their first shot on net. Jordan Geike converted 1:46 into the game, firing a shot to the top shelf after a back-to-front pass from Sal Viviano. Youngstown answered with a power play goal from Kamden Kaiser at 13:33, but Waterloo grabbed the lead back just 44 seconds later when Colin Dustin’s high tip redirected past Peter Chlebowski. “He had almost zero chance on both goals against,” said Paetsch of Chlebowski. “A goalie can fold in a situation like that; he didn’t. He just stepped-up big time.”
From that point, Youngstown looked to their captain. After a scoreless second period, Waterloo got an early power play in the third. When a dump in came to the side of the net, Chlebowski played the puck up the near wall. McKinnon chipped the puck past his man and raced down ice on a breakaway. Coming down the left side, McKinnon cut across the net mouth and put a backhander past Charlie Menard, tying the game at 4:11. The Phantoms turned up the pressure, outshooting Waterloo 15-5 in the third period, but neither team could dent the scoreboard further until overtime. McKinnon carried the puck from coast to coast in the bonus session, coming all the way across the ice from the right to left wing wall. Bringing the puck below the bottom of the left circle, he whipped a severe angle shot over the short-side shoulder of Menard and into the twine to give Youngstown the 3-2 win. It was the second career overtime game-winning goal for McKinnon, who also gave Youngstown the win on December 27, 2025 against Chicago. “(Malachi) is growing,” said Paetsch. “As a captain, he had to learn how to be a leader. We’ve had a lot of talks; he’s an amazing kid, but he’s had to grow into that leadership role. He’s starting to understand what it means to be a leader, what it means to be a captain. And that’s a captain taking his team to victory.”
Menard stopped 37-of-40 while suffering his third overtime loss of the year. Chlebowski stopped 26-of-28 while earning his first USHL win, as well as his first assist, which came on the shorthanded goal by McKinnon in the third period.
Youngstown wraps up their three-in-three weekend with a Sunday matinee against the Eastern Conference-leading Cedar Rapids RoughRiders. Puck drop is scheduled for 4:00pm.
BY THE NUMBERS
Shots – 40
Saves – 26
Power Play – 1/5
Penalty Kill – 7/7
Goals – Kaiser, McKinnon (2)
Assists – Chlebowski, Cover, Thompson, Zajic
---
PHOTO CREDIT SCOTT GALVIN/SCOTT GALVIN PHOTOGRAPHY